How to Choose Climbing Holds for a University Rec Center

By Sam Gotthelf | April 2026

---

If you're managing a university climbing wall, the holds bolted to your panels are the single biggest factor in whether students actually come back after their first session. A wall with the wrong holds — too aggressive, too uniform, too worn — quietly kills engagement. The right hold inventory turns a wall into a campus destination.

After leading hold selection and procurement for the University of Pittsburgh's 49-foot Walltopia wall and advising other university programs on their setups, here's how I approach the process.

Start With Your User Demographics, Not Your Budget

Most university rec centers serve three overlapping populations: complete beginners trying climbing for the first time, intermediate recreational climbers who come a few times a week, and competitive team athletes training at a high level. Your hold inventory needs to serve all three, and the ratio matters.

At a typical university facility, roughly 60–70% of wall traffic comes from beginners and casual users. That means much of your hold budget should go toward large, positive shapes: big jugs, deep slopers with incut lips, and footholds that are easy to stand on in rental shoes. These aren't exciting to buy, but they're what keeps first-timers from leaving frustrated.

The remaining budget goes toward more technical shapes for your intermediate and competitive climbers: crimps, pinches, volumes, and coordination-style holds that enable interesting movement at higher grades.

Diversify Your Brands

One of the most common mistakes I see in university wall builds is ordering exclusively from a single hold manufacturer. Every brand has a design philosophy, some lean toward competition-style shapes, others toward gym-friendly ergonomics, and others toward aesthetic or organic designs. A single-brand wall ends up feeling monotone.

I typically recommend sourcing from five to seven brands to get variety in texture, shape language, and size distribution.

Think About Durability and Maintenance

University holds take a beating. High traffic, rental shoes with aggressive rubber, and inexperienced climbers cross-loading holds in unintended ways all contribute to faster wear. Polyurethane holds with good texture depth tend to last longer than cheaper resin alternatives.

Plan for attrition. I budget about 15–20% extra beyond what's needed for the initial set, specifically for replacements in the first two years. Footholds and juggy beginner holds wear fastest and should be the bulk of your replacement stock.

Size Distribution Matters More Than You Think

A hold order that looks great on a spreadsheet can fail on the wall if the size distribution is off. University walls need a much higher proportion of large holds (hand-size and bigger) than a commercial gym might. I generally target something like:

• Extra-large / volumes: 10–15% of total count

• Large (jugs, big slopers): 30–35%

• Medium (edges, pinches, moderate slopers): 25–30%

• Small (crimps, technical edges): 15–20%

• Footholds (dedicated): 10–15%

This skews larger than what most vendors suggest in their "starter packages," which are often designed for commercial gyms with more experienced clientele.

I built a free hold inventory tracker template that I use on real projects. It covers size distribution, brand mix, hardware, budget tracking, and replacement stock. Get it here.

Don't Overlook Volumes and Features

Volumes — the large geometric shapes that screw over the wall surface and create three-dimensional terrain, are some of the most impactful additions to a university wall. They make easy climbing more interesting (beginners love the variety), create natural rest positions, and give setters dramatically more options for route design.

I recommend allocating at least 10% of your hold budget specifically to volumes.

Coordinate With Your Setters Early

If you have route setters on staff, or plan to hire them, involve them in the hold selection process before you place your order. Setters know which shapes work on your specific wall angles, which brands they can create the best movement with, and where the gaps in your current inventory are.

If you don't have setters yet, that's a conversation worth having before you spend five figures on holds. A consultant or experienced setter can review your wall design and recommend an inventory that will give your setting team the tools they need from day one.

The Bottom Line

Hold selection isn't glamorous, but it's one of the highest-leverage decisions in a wall build. Get it right and your wall stays fresh, engaging, and well-trafficked for years. Get it wrong and you'll be re-ordering within a semester.

If you're planning a university wall build or looking to refresh your existing hold inventory, I'm happy to talk through your specific situation. Reach out here for a free initial consultation.

My Custom Hold Order Spreadsheet

Sam Gotthelf is a climbing wall consultant, USAC-certified route setter, and mechanical engineering student at the University of Pittsburgh. He led the hold selection and procurement for Pitt's 49-foot Walltopia wall and advises universities on wall design, operations, and routesetting programs. Learn more at samgotthelf.com.